Marcelle 2-in-1 Retractable Eyeliner, Charcoal, Waterproof, Easy-To-Smudge, Smokey Eye, Long-Lasting 12h, Fragrance-Free, Hypoallergenic, Cruelty-Free, 0.31 g

I like the Marcelle retractable eyeliner much more than their regular gel eyeliner. It seems to go on thicker, though both versions are soft, glide on easily, and have staying power(waterproof). I selected the brown, which goes great with my blond hair highlights. I switched from the black and have gotten many compliments. I was about to get a second one just to have it on hand but they have raised the price almost 25% for the brown retractable version in the past week so I will wait and buy it when needed. It must be popular.

This is a beautiful, deep color eyeliner. It does stay where you use it which was part of deciding to buy it.

I have osteoarthritis of my hands and I found the packaging of the eyeliner pencil itself was extremely hard to open....

I have very sensitive eyes but love wearing eyeliner. This brand has been the only eyeliner that I’ve used that hasn’t broken me out in bumps. It also lasted throughout the entire work day! I will continue to use this! Highly recommend if you have sensitive eyes!

Eyeliner is soft and easy to apply. It stays all day and there are no problems in removing at the end of the day. Good quality.

Goes on easily but has a tendency to flake off. But looks good while it’s on.

I’ve been using this eyeliner for years. It’s gentle but long-lasting and never causes any discomfort.

The liner breaks off as you’re applying it to your eyes keeps happening to me so I’m losing half of the product!